TL;DR

To screen a tenant, write your rental criteria before you list, then collect one application with written consent from every applicant. Pull the reports your criteria name, decide against the criteria, and send an adverse action notice if a report shaped even part of a refusal or worse terms. Then dispose of the reports securely. This follows US federal guidance from the FTC.

To screen a tenant, write your rental criteria before you list, then collect one application and written consent from every applicant. Pull the reports, decide against the criteria, and send an adverse action notice if a report shaped a "no". Then dispose of the reports securely.

The checks matter less than their sequence, because the sequence is where landlords get into trouble. It covers US federal guidance from the FTC. State and local rules on fees, records and criteria differ, so check yours before you list.

What is the right order for screening a tenant?

Six steps, in this order. Each one protects the next.

  1. Criteria first: write down what qualifies an applicant before anyone applies.
  2. One application, with consent: every applicant fills in the same form and gives written permission for reports.
  3. Pull the reports: credit, rental history and any other check your criteria name.
  4. Decide against the criteria: the written ones, applied the same way to everyone.
  5. Send the notice: if a report played any part in a refusal or worse terms, send an adverse action notice.
  6. Dispose of the reports: securely, once you are finished with them.

The sections below take each step in turn. The two that trip people up are the first and the fifth.

StepWhat you do
1. Criteria firstWrite down what qualifies an applicant before anyone applies
2. One application, with consentEvery applicant fills in the same form and gives written permission for reports
3. Pull the reportsCredit, rental history and any other check your criteria name
4. Decide against the criteriaThe written ones, applied the same way to everyone
5. Send the noticeIf a report played any part in a refusal or worse terms, send an adverse action notice
6. Dispose of the reportsSecurely, once you are finished with them

Why write the criteria before listing?

Because criteria written after you meet someone look like an excuse. Criteria written before look like a policy.

Put them on one page. Name the income ratio you need and the rental history you accept. Say what a report must or must not show, and how many occupants the unit takes. Share the page with every applicant, or link it from the listing. Then apply it to everyone identically, including the friend of a friend.

Be careful with blanket rules. The FTC guide Using Consumer Reports: What Landlords Need to Know carries a warning here. It says refusing anyone with a criminal record may violate the Fair Housing Act. A rule that sounds tidy on paper can still be the wrong rule.

One form, the same for every applicant. Identity, contact details, current and past addresses, employment and income, references and occupants are the usual core. The rental application form template lays out those fields with a reason for each, so there is no need to reprint them here.

Consent belongs on the same form. A landlord needs a permissible purpose, such as a rental application, or written permission to obtain a consumer report, per the FTC's landlord guide. A signed consent line on the application removes the argument.

For a shop, office or warehouse, the commercial lease application template asks about the business rather than the household. Both sit in the form template library.

Which reports should a landlord pull?

Pull the ones your written criteria name, and only those. If the criteria mention credit, pull credit. If they mention rental history, call the previous landlords too.

Pull the same reports for every applicant who reaches this stage. A landlord who runs an extra check on one applicant has quietly changed the criteria for one person.

How should you record each decision?

Write one short note per applicant, on the day you decide. Note which criteria they met, which they missed, and which report you relied on.

The note does two jobs. It tells you at once whether an adverse action notice is due. It also shows, months later, that every applicant was judged on the same page. Keep it with the application, under the same retention period.

What is an adverse action notice, and when do you send one?

An adverse action notice tells an applicant that a consumer report affected your decision. According to the FTC, you send one when a decision rests even partly on a report. That covers a denial, a higher rent or deposit, or a co-signer requirement.

"Even partly" is the phrase to remember. If a report was one of three reasons, the notice is still due.

The FTC's guide sets out what the notice contains:

  • The name, address and phone number of the reporting agency.
  • A statement that the agency did not make the decision.
  • The applicant's right to dispute the report's accuracy with the agency.
  • The applicant's right to a free copy of the report if they ask within 60 days.

If you used a credit score, the notice also gives the score, its source and its date, per the same FTC page. It adds the range of possible scores and the key factors behind it. Keep a template ready. Writing one from scratch on the day you turn someone down is how fields go missing.

How should a landlord dispose of screening reports?

Securely, when you are finished with them. The FTC says reports must be disposed of securely, in its landlord guide.

In practice, that means shredding paper copies and deleting digital ones from every place they landed. Check the inbox, the downloads folder and any shared drive. Decide how long you keep the application itself under your state's rules, and write that period beside your criteria.

Which listing site sent your best renters?

Screening tells you who qualified. It rarely tells you where the qualified applicants came from, and that is the number that decides where you list next time.

Record the channel on every application. If applicants reach your own website's application form from a listing site, a social post or a search, lead source tracking records which one. Lead Source does that with one line of code in the site header, and each application arrives with its channel, campaign and landing page. The rental application template fills in online and downloads as a PDF or Word file. Other ready-made forms, and what belongs on each, are covered on the Lead Source blog under forms and templates.

One honest limit. An applicant who applies inside a listing platform never touches your form, so that platform's own reports are the only record. Point listings at your own application where you can.

After a few vacancies, compare channels by approved tenants, not by enquiries. One site may send many applicants and few approvals. Another may send three and fill the unit.